Eats
Overwhelming response as usual to this category, more evidence of what our readers do when given lots of choices. (Perhaps this is why the local politics categories get less traffic?)
Sometimes it seems the more things change, the more they stay the same, with Kuni’s back on the list for best sushi, despite having closed and reopened in a different location, alongside Kibarashi, which took over at Kuni’s old spot.
Best new restaurant finalists include the revamped (Bistro Europa was previously a small retail venue), the restored (North reopened the dining room in the classic Lenox Hotel) and the reimagined (Stillwater makes use of the glorious space that was Lord Chumley’s).
Empire Grill and the Chocolate Bar bring exciting brand new builds to different sides of the city: The Chocolate Bar’s downtown digs in the Hampton Inn showcase skilled metalwork, a decadent chocolate fountain and a continuous screening of Charlie & the Chocolate Factory (original version) playing on monitors in both bathrooms. The ambitious Empire Grill is a huge, multi-level place with an atrium and modern, open-air feeling—all light and air as opposed to the Chocolate Bar’s more sensual atmosphere.
The most genre-busting responses to our poll were found in the categories of best bar food, best Chinese, best late-night eats, best service and best steak.
For instance, the best bar food category takes us from the venerable Old Pink, with its famous steak sandwiches smothered in peppers and onions, to one of Buffalo’s best-loved gay bars, Buddies II, which may be the only dance club to serve food and do a helluva job of it, to the cavernous Pearl St. Grill & Brewery, which also boasts a full menu and table service to boot.
Best steak sees the popular take-out joint Jim’s Steak Out on the same list with one of the city’s high-roller destinations, Buffalo Chophouse.
Equally incongruent are the nominees for best Chinese, from the Elmwood Village/Buff State area take-out favorite Great Wall to the one-time Michelin-rated Ontario establishment Ming Teh, whose escargots in black bean sauce and reputation for authentic, gourmet Chinese food make it a destination restaurant for many on this side of the border.
Best late-night eats, if you follow our readers’ recommendations, could land you at the considerably upscale Mother’s, where you can usually order from both the dinner menu (think soft-shell crabs in season, filet mignon, smoked trout salad) and the bar menu (quesadillas, French fries, meatloaf sandwiches) until the wee hours; on the flip side, Buffalo’s own local Tex-Mex chain Mighty Taco is nominated in the same category.
Finally, the finalists for best service prove that interpretation is everything, with the always bustling and super-efficient Pano’s neck-and-neck with the sophisticated and sublimely elegant Rue Franklin.
Makes you wonder if it all depends on what the definition of “best” is after all.
—k o’day
best new restaurant
Bistro Europa
Stillwater
North
Chocolate Bar
Empire Grill
most romantic
restaurant
Salvatore’s
Mother’s
Hutch’s
Left Bank
Shango
best place for a
cheap date
Pano’s
Mighty Taco
Amy’s Place
Jim’s Steakout
Louie’s
best cheap breakfast
Pano’s
Towne
Amy’s Place
Bertha’s
Betty’s
best waterfront
restaurant
The Hatch
Harry’s
Root 5
Shanghai Red’s
Dock at the Bay
best late-night eats
Pano’s
Jim’s Steakout
Mother’s
Mighty Taco
Towne
best diner
Lake Effect
Pano’s
Amy’s Place
Towne
Kosta’s
best patio
Cozumel
Pano’s
Mother’s
Cecelia’s
Shanghai Red’s
best service
Shango
Hutch’s
Pano’s
Left Bank
Salvatore’s
best takeout/delivery
Kuni’s
Just Pizza
La Nova
Jim’s Steakout
Casa Di Pizza
best brunch
Off the Wall
Betty’s
Left Bank
Shango
Cole’s
best dessert
Sweet Tooth
Butterwood
Dessert Deli
Chocolate Bar
Delish
best deli
Globe Market
Marco’s
Guercio & Sons
Joe’s Deli
X-cel Produce
best bagel
Bagel Jay’s
Wegman’s
Elmwood Bagel
Spot
Amy’s Place
best barbecue
BW
Kentucky Greg’s
Buffalo BBQ and Brew
Fat Bob’s
Donnie’s Smokehouse
best beef on weck
The Bar Bill
Charlie the Butcher
Anderson’s
Schwabl’s
Swiston’s
best wings
La Nova
Gabriel’s Gate
The Bar Bill
Anchor Bar
Duff’s
best fish fry
Hamlin House
Papa Jake’s
Hoak’s
Gabriel’s Gate
McPartlan’s
best ice cream/
frozen yogurt
Anderson’s
Sweet Tooth
Antoinette’s
Fowler’s
Hannah’s
best burger
Grover’s
Jim’s
Sterling Place
Jimmie Mac’s
K. Gallagher’s
best hot dog
Street vendors
Taffy’s
Ted’s
Louie’s
Connor’s
best french fries
Ted’s
Jim’s Steakout
Louie’s
Papa Jake’s
Duff’s
best pasta
Chef’s
Frank’s Sunny Italy
Santasiero’s
La Bella Sicilia
Carmine’s
best pizza
La Nova
Mr. Pizza
Bocce
Casa Di Pizza
Franco’s
best salad
Globe Market
Le Metro
Pano’s
Shango
Brodo
best sub
Jim’s Steakout
Wegman’s
Mike’s
DiBella’s
John & Mary’s
best steak
Hutch’s
Buffalo Chophouse
E.B. Green’s
Fiamma
Jim’s Steakout
best sausage
Spar’s
Mineo & Sapio
Scime’s
Johnny’s
Erie County Fair
best seafood
Boston Hotel
Harry’s
La Marina
Hutch’s
Hayes Fish Company
best chinese
Great Wall
Taste Good
Chang’s
May Jen
Ming Teh
best japanese/sushi
O
Kuni’s
Kibarashi
Fuji Grill
Shogun
best thai/vietnamese
Saigon Bangkok
Saigon Cafe
Taste of Thai
King and I
Papaya
best french
Coda
Rue Franklin
Le Metro
Left Bank
Bacchus
best greek
Towne
Kosta’s
Ambrosia
Pano’s
Mythos
best indian
Taste of India
India Gate
Tandoori
Star of India
Kebab and Curry
best polish
Polish Villa
Bistro Europa
Broadway Market
Peter K’s
Ray’s Lounge
“My grandmother”
best italian
Frank’s Sunny Italy
Santasiero’s
Chef’s
John’s Italian Village
La Bella Sicilia
best mexican/tex-mex
Cozumel
Gramma Mora’s
Cinco de Mayo
El Canelo
Mighty Taco
best middle eastern
Falafel Bar
Sahara Grill
Amy’s Place
Teta’s
Byblos
best vegetarian
Betty’s
Amy’s Place
Falafel Bar
Off the Wall
Lexington Co-op
best bar food
Buddies II
Gabriel’s Gate
Cole’s
The Old Pink
Pearl Street Grill & Brewery
Issue Navigation> Issue Index > v6n16: Best of Buffalo (4/19/07) > AV Best of Buffalo > Eats This Week's Issue • Artvoice Daily • Artvoice TV • Events Calendar • Classifieds |