Current Issue: Artvoice v7n49, week of Thursday December 4 » back issues
Film Reviews |
Wands Away, Please: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenixby Mike Schenkel |
|
|
The quick moving, closely edited plot will satisfy fans, but what’s left unexplained may overwhelm newcomers to the Harry Potter saga, in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix.
Fortunately for David Heyman, the producer of this film and its predecessor, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, there are plenty of fans—many of whom were willing to dress up in full Wizard and Death Eater costumes for the opening night of the film. If you are thinking of dressing up for the film, take warning: theatres may have their own “Defense Against the Dark Arts” initiative going on. At the preview screening, I overheard a young witch getting her handbag searched by security guards who wouldn’t permit her to enter the theater with her wand. “I’m sorry, miss, you’ll need to put that back out in your car.” Really? Yup.
As we join our hero (once again played by Daniel Radcliffe), the wizard authorities have decided that the return of Lord Voldemort (the event ending Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire) is a fiction invented by the attention seeking Harry and his schoolmaster Albus Dumbledore (Michael Gambon), and want Harry silenced. While Dark dreams continue to bother Harry’s sleep, the Ministry of Magic installs Dolores Umbridge (Imelda Staunton) as Hogwarts Inquisitor in an attempt to discredit Dumbledore, and prevent students from becoming endangered by spells meant to defend themselves from the Dark Arts. Umbridge, like the theatre security guards, will not even allow students their magic wands in class.
The story follows struggles in parallel paths. The adult wizards who know of Voldemort’s return are secretly working as “The Order of the Phoenix” to prepare to fight the anticipated spread of dark magic and evil. At the prompting of his friends, Harry forms a Defense Against the Dark Arts club called “Dumbledore’s Army,” to help the young wizards at Hogwarts prepare to fight Dark Magic, in spite of Umbridge’s useless “Ministry Approved” curriculum. Meanwhile, Harry struggles to maintain his self-confidence and overcome his anger as the Ministry of Magic continues to insist that he is a liar, and that nothing is wrong.
The established cast members turn in solid performances. Alan Rickman is on perfect form as Professor Severus Snape. Emma Watson, who plays Harry’s friend Hermione, delivered a seemingly natural performance. New to the story are Luna Lovegood, a quiet student played by Evanna Lynch, and Staunton’s cruelly totalitarian Umbridge. Both actresses fulfilled the characters well, in spite of the deceptively “flat” roles that each character played in the plot of the book. Also debuting to the series is Helena Bonham Carter as Azkaban prisoner Bellatrix Lestrange, a role she plays with evil vigor.
As the loyalty of Harry’s friends’ is tested during their fifth year of study at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, a sense of family builds around Harry, Ron and Hermione. The genuineness of the feeling of family was of unexpected depth, with many well-acted scenes providing a foothold for viewers who don’t know enough about Quidditch to notice its conspicuous absence from the film.
Even without wizard sporting events, the film has amazing, seamlessly integrated special effects. Most of the film’s audience will love the grand atmosphere that this installment brings to their beloved main characters’ stories. (This despite the fact that Order of the Phoenix is something of a break from the previous Harry Potter films, using a new screenwriter—Michael Goldenberg, who wrote the 2003 Peter Pan, replacing Steve Kloves—and a non-name value director—David Yates, much respected in Britain for his television work). The rest of us can just try to keep the lengthening list of inexplicable, magical people and items which we are required to recognize in order—a feat that is no problem for thirteen-year-olds, but which may leave the uninitiated feeling lost.
|
Issue Navigation> Issue Index > v6n28: Timber! (7/12/07) > Film Reviews > Wands Away, Please: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix This Week's Issue • Artvoice Daily • Events Calendar • Classifieds |
Artvoice Blog Headlines
JP Losman is sacked. AV correspondent Dave Staba reports…posted December 2, 11:16 am on Artvoice DailyJP Losman is sacked. AV correspondent Dave Staba reports on Sunday’s loss from the cheap seats at Ralph Wilson Stadium: Trent Edwards rolled to his right. And he rolled to his right. And then he rolled some more. Finally, a moment before he would have run completely off the field, Buffalo’s quarterback flung the ball towards his intended receiver, who was evidently sitting in a third-row seat near the southerly corner at the tunnel end of Ralph Wilson Stadium... (more) |
West Side Neighborhood Housing Servicesposted November 28, 3:44 pm on Artvoice DailyAs promised in this article, the membership list for West Side Neighborhood Housing Services is right here. Highlighted in yellow are city employees who report to the mayor or their relatives; highlighted in pink are other city employees. Most of the highlighted names (though not all) are new members, who joined just in time to vote at last Thursday’s annual members meeting, when Harvey Garrett was voted off WSNHS’s board... (more) |
On the Waterfrontposted November 26, 2:00 pm on Artvoice DailySo you think Buffalo has a hard time figuring out what to do with its waterfront, do ya? Mad that we can’t just build a signature bridge, huh? Madder still that we can’t just knock the Skyway bridge down? Furious with obstructionists who don’t want a Bass Pro Shop? Livid about the ice boom? And don’t even get you started about all the blind, misguided fools who can’t see that a huge casino downtown will turn our city around? Yes, my friend, you do in fact have all the answers... (more) |
Chow Chocolat welcomes Denise Sperry’s Watercolor Exhibition…posted November 26, 12:46 pm on Chew on ThisWatercolor Painting by Denise Sperry Merging the fine arts with gastronomic art, Chow Chocolat (731 Main Street, Buffalo, 843.4388) is now featuring a watercolor exhibition by Denise Sperry. A reception commencing Sperry’s works will take place on December 5th, 2008 (6-9 PM)... (more) |
GRILLE 620 (Wine… Down the Weekend)posted November 26, 11:34 am on Chew on ThisIf you haven’t already checked out “Wine… Down the Weekend” at Grille 620, (620 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, 886.2121) GO! This has to be one of the best deals in the city of Buffalo. Every Friday & Saturday, patrons can choose a complimentary bottle from the bistro’s extensive wine list to accompany any 2 entrees... (more) |
Another Voiceposted November 26, 10:11 am on Artvoice DailyHere’s something that drives me crazy about the Buffalo News: the “Another Voice” column on the editorial page. It would be a nice idea, except that so often it is not given over to “another” voice. It is given, rather, to the same old voices: to people who are frequently quoted as sources in articles, who are in positions of political or economic power, to folks whose job is to push agendas—to people, in other words, who have no difficulty making their voices heard... (more) |
Who Goes Where When Hillary Goes to State?posted November 19, 12:04 pm on Artvoice DailyCity Hall News has flow_chart that tracks who might replace who, from Hillary’s Senate seat on down (click to expand or follow the link—it’s an awkward shape): |
It’s Robert Rich Sr. All High Stadiumposted November 14, 5:05 pm on Artvoice DailyThese new signs properly label the structure. We’ve been reading recent stories in the Buffalo News about sportswriter Tom Borrelli’s terrible fall last week at the old All High Stadium. He’s currently battling life-threatening injuries... (more) |
CWM Fined for Violationsposted November 14, 2:41 pm on Artvoice DailyHere's a picture of the sort of thing that got CWM in trouble This week Chemical Waste Management was fined $175,000 by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation for violating its permits and the state’s hazardous waste laws... (more) |
Musical Chairsposted November 14, 12:51 pm on Artvoice DailyThe AP reports that Hillary Clinton met with Barack Obama in Chicago yesterday, adding fuel to speculation that she might be Obama’s choice for secretary of state. If that happens, it has long been rumored that Brian Higgins would be appointed to her Senate seat... (more) |
Paint the Townposted November 14, 11:06 am on Artvoice DailyLate last night, at the tail end of one of the few weeks in the past year in which we did not publish anything snarky about anybody, someone threw two gallons of paint on our front doors. Seems a waste; we hadn’t even earned it. Nonetheless, we were cleaning up all morning... (more) |
Old Editions Book Shopposted November 13, 1:58 pm on Artvoice DailyAV videographer Matt Quinn tours Old Editions, an often overlooked treasure at the corner of Oak and Huron Streets downtown: show enclosure (video/x-flv; 21.29 MB) |
Mazzariello’s Ristorante & Martini Barposted November 7, 4:30 pm on Chew on ThisPhoto taken by Rose Mattrey From Antipasti to Primi to Secondi, Mazzariello’s (114 Bloomfield Ave, Lancaster, 206.0561) has conquered the map of Italian cooking. Your palate will be exposed to an array of spices, herbs, and ingredients indigenous to Northern & Southern Italy... (more) |
Post Election Bits & Bytesposted November 7, 12:02 am on Tech VoiceElection ‘08 is now in the history books - so I figured it’s time to take a look backward, and a look forward at some relevant headlines. Hacking Democracy First, we’ll take a look at one of the best kept secrets of the campaign season, from both sides, care of a Newsweek article published just today... (more) |
Artvoice TV: Latest Additions » more on AVTV
Punisher: War Zoneposted December 3, 4:04 pm on channel Movie Trailers
|
Ashes of Time Reduxposted December 3, 3:58 pm on channel Movie Trailers
|
Dr. Riyaz Hassanali: The TANNING BED, Yes? No?posted December 2, 4:57 pm on channel Health
|
Ani DiFranco at Babevilleposted December 1, 8:19 pm on channel Music
|
Peanut Brittle Satellite with Jeff Mcleod of Lazlo Holyfieldposted November 29, 1:44 pm on channel Music
|
Artisans Bazaar on Elmwoodposted November 29, 1:16 pm on channel Art
|
City Mission: Food for the Needyposted November 28, 08:47 am on channel Local Interest
|
Turkey Trot: Buffalo's 113thposted November 27, 5:57 pm on channel Events
|
Dr. Riyaz Hassanali: Talks about BOTOXposted November 26, 5:46 pm on channel Health
|
Viva Vivaldi Festival @ The First Presbyterian Churchposted November 23, 3:48 pm on channel Music
|
The Burchfield-Penney Opensposted November 23, 2:33 pm on channel Art
|
Synecdoche, New Yorkposted November 23, 12:24 am on channel Movie Trailers
|
One Day You'll Understandposted November 23, 12:12 am on channel Movie Trailers
|
Four Christmasesposted November 23, 11:53 am on channel Movie Trailers
|
Australiaposted November 23, 11:46 am on channel Movie Trailers
|







Subscribe