Our Zany March Toward Intolerance
by Michael I. Niman
Decamping the Roma, bashing the mosque, underwriting the hate-mongers
Things aren’t looking too good on the tolerance front lately. In a move darkly reminiscent of the European pogroms of the 1930s, France’s beleaguered right-wing president, Nicolas Sarkozy, is ordering mass deportations of ethnic Roma. Like Europe’s Jews, who before the Holocaust were a minority in every European country and a majority in none, the Roma too are present across the continent as an oppressed minority without an independent homeland. And like the Jews, they too were rounded up by racist governments and sent to concentration camps during the Holocaust. So it’s not too much of a stretch to say someone hit the replay button here. Sarkozy’s government is borrowing one of the oldest scripts from the playbook, tossing raw meat to the xenophobes by scapegoating a minority, all in order to distract the public from his own government’s failings.
The Roma certainly make for an easy target. Most of the world knows them only by the racial slur “gypsies,” which is so common that Roma themselves sometimes have been forced to use the term to avoid confusion when talking to an ignorant majority. The “G” word is like the “N” word, only much more popular—so popular, in fact, that the United States’ largest news service, the Associated Press, headlined their Sarkozy-friendly article last week: “France to Repatriate 93 Gypsies to Romania.” “The flights,” the AP article continues, “are part of a crackdown by France’s conservative President Nicolas Sarkozy,” who “has linked Gypsies, or Roma, to crime and spearheaded a campaign to dismantle their illegal camps and send some home to Eastern Europe.”
Mosque-gate Crusaders
If you’re feeling a bit smug, thinking maybe us Americans, minus perhaps the AP, are somehow above the amnesiac French, you might want to take a gander at our own nation’s own metastasizing “Ground Zero Mosque” controversy. Having trumped catastrophic climate change, the BP oil spill, and all news coverage of pet torturers, this fabricated controversy is emerging at the center of the 2010 Republican election strategy. Muslims, like the Roma in France, are fair game, so the media is plugging away with polls, idiot-on-the-street interviews, and all sorts of intellectual gasoline to fan the flames of this season’s hottest non-story story.
Of course it’s not exactly a mosque, and it’s not exactly at Ground Zero, but hey, it’s not exactly a news story, either—but then again it seems to becoming one. The proposed building is actually a 13-story structure with a community pool, a gym and fitness center, a 500-seat auditorium and theater, and a prayer space, which we’ll call a “mosque.” It would be two blocks over from the edge of the World Trade Center site, and would contain the neighborhood’s third mosque, with the other two being four and 12 blocks away. Houses of worship and cultural centers aren’t really anything new in lower Manhattan. For example, St. Paul’s Chapel and St. Peter’s Church are both less than one block from Ground Zero, the John Street Methodist Church and the Battery Park Synagogue are both one block away, Trinity Church is two blocks away, as is the Amish Market, as would be the new Islamic center. The Museum of Jewish Heritage is five blocks away. You get the idea. There’s nothing novel here.
But non-issues like this always bring out our own loony, native-born Sarkozys. Seemingly back from the dead, we have former Republican House Speaker Newt (as in the insect-eating amphibian who’s comfy both wallowing in the mud and slithering on dry ground) Gingrich. He’s found a ready and willing media machine to disseminate his bile. This “family values” adulterer who sprung divorce papers on his wife as she lay on a hospital bed recovering from cancer surgery recently argued, “Nazis don’t have the right to put up a sign next to the Holocaust Museum in Washington,” as if such an abomination would be analogous to American Muslims constructing a community center in lower Manhattan. He went on to explain that President Barack Obama, a former constitutional attorney, in explaining that an Islamic organization has a legally protected right to construct a community center on their private property, a concept that like family values is a cornerstone of Republican identity, was actually “pandering to radical Islam.” This was too much even for a normally fire-breathing Pat Buchanan, who attacked Gingrich for being a “political opportunist.” Perhaps Newt’s courting the loonier-than-Palin vote.
Carl’s madmen
But it gets better. Buffalo developer (and, if you follow the public money supporting his development career, welfare queen) Carl Paladino, now a contender for the Republican nomination for New York governor, is also grandstanding on the issue, apparently courting the loonier-than-Newt vote. According to Paladino, “This isn’t about moderate, peace-loving Muslims; this is about a sect of radical fundamentalist Islamists who attacked our nation and who are tied to this mosque by an ideology of hate…This is the same ideology that advocates stoning women and gay people to death.”
Okay. So Paladino doesn’t want to stone women to death, but that’s about as liberal as he gets on the gender front. This is the same Carl Paladino who was distributing internet bestiality pornography to his email circle, including a rather explicit photo of a horse penetrating a woman’s vagina. The gubernatorial hopeful, a darling of New York’s Tea Party, defended himself, explaining to the Buffalo News that he only sent the bestiality pornography to “a very specific bunch of friends.” No biggie—just guy fun. It seems that Paladino either really likes horses or he really hates women, or perhaps both. Another Paladino email contained a photo of a plane about to crash on a group of running black children, with the caption, “Run Nigger, Run.” This also, no doubt, went to a very specific group of friends.
These misogynist and racist emails were made public early in the campaign, when Paladino was relatively unknown across the state. Rather than kill his fledging candidacy, the scandal seems to have ignited it. Hell, everyone sends that sort of stuff to a very specific group of friends, folks said. Carl’s just a victim of the liberal media.
Today that same media has all but forgotten about Carl the racist bestiality fetishist, and regrooved him into Paladino the populist. Not a madman, but a man with a message. And hence, in this better-than-France country of ours, suddenly thousands of other madmen are peppering their dandelion-free lawns with “I’m Mad Too Carl” signs. Make of it what you will.
Of course we shouldn’t easily dismiss Paladino and the loonier-than-Newt crowd as just being good for a few hoots. They might very well have some staying power, at least in the Republican party. A recent Pew poll found that a full 18 percent of Americans, and 41 percent of Republicans, now believe that the Hawaiian-born Obama was either “probably” or “definitely” born in a foreign country. As for his birth certificate? Well, the Kenyans put it there in Honolulu back in 1961, knowing their sleeper agent would one day dupe the country into electing him president.
Target’s hate-monger
Then there’s the Target controversy. Y’all remember that little Supreme Court ruling last September that paved the way for corporations to dump unlimited amounts of cash into political campaigns, essentially closing the door on our little experiment with democracy? Well, it seems Target recently donated what Tony Soprano would term “150 large” to a political action committee, Minnesota Forward, that’s underwriting the candidacy of anti-gay zealot Tom Emmer for governor of Minnesota. As for Emmer, the Minnesota Independent reports that his political organization donated money to support a “Christian” hate rock band fronted by Bradlee Dean, who recently spoke in support of the practice of Islamic extremists executing people for being gay or lesbian. Get it? Community center—bad. Fellow nut jobs killing gays—good.
Target’s CEO, Gregg Steinhafel , in response to the controversy, sent a memo to Target workers citing the corporation’s rhetorical commitment to gay rights. The donation, Target brass explained, was a business decision and in no way was connected to Emmer’s stance on gay folks. Just buying a bit of influence in the statehouse. Understand?
Diversity is a thin veneer under which any bigot who supports corporate tax cuts can get a pass. We’ve also seen this before, with corporations sucking up to repressive governments around the world, all in the interest of shoring up their bottom lines. Think Chevron in contemporary Nigeria, or IBM in Nazi Germany. Apparently following this logic, Best Buy forked over another $100,000 to Minnesota Forward. Prepare for this to be a depressing election cycle. Perhaps, as his madmen help him surge in the polls, Paladino too might cash in on some Target and Best Buy largesse.
Reader Comments (posting new comments is closed!)
|
Debbie 26 Aug 2010, 13:38
Wow - Michael, you really have it out for Carl don't you? You have yet to get pass the email thing, you can't and won't even openly look at what he has to offer to fixing NYS problems, including, helping welfare recipients, cutting (not capping) taxes, cutting spending except to those of police and health care, and most of all taking on the corrupt people in Albany. Has Andrew even suggested any of those reforms? Has Lazio - how would we know, he won't even have a debate with Carl about such important issues. So Michael why are you bashing Carl so much, you must be afraid of something, are your friends the corrupt ones, and Carl might be coming after "your" friends? Get over the email thing, it's a done and dead deal. My 85 year old Aunt sent me 2 of those emails years and years ago, she's not a racist and certainly doesn't hate women, nor am I but we still laughed for a second about them and probably even forwarded them on. What are you going to do now, break into my 85 year old Aunt's email and mine? All I have to say about you not moving on about the email thing is , I would LOVE to see your personal emails. It would probably show you are a saint huh? Probably live in that glass house HUH? I think NOT!
Brian 26 Aug 2010, 23:18
If some serious crimes suddenly creeped up on your back door, you might be a little intolerant as well. Everyone wants the equality and tolerance until its in their own back yard causing problems. Wake up.
Max 27 Aug 2010, 18:10
Let's not forget Carl's e-mail excesses "Debbie," because not everyone is an unabashed apologist for those behaviors. I get e-mail forwards from 2nd generation immigrants which viscously attack and depict recent arrivals from other countries as well as those who follow of different faiths. Let's also remember that Carl is running for a statewide office which represents all of the citizens of New York State, not just the "few" who're on his select forward list or for that matter, yours either.
Jay BURNEY 28 Aug 2010, 09:38
Another great column michael. Keep them coming! Regarding the Roma- This is one of the most important and under reported stories of recent times. Your equating it with the Holocaust is right on. The current global war on poverty is about exterminating the poor of the world. Regarding the "mosque"- isnt this cultural center sort of like the JCC or the YMCA or YWCA? Don't we fight wars and sacrifice soldiers and civilians to protect the rights of religion? If people want to revisit it, lets have that dialogue plain and clear! regards newt- he is creepier than ever but please dont slander the salamander. These creatures are a vital part of our ecology. Gingrich does not deserve the comparison to such a beautiful and necessary creature. (ok forgive my value judgement- newt may be beautiful and necessary to some) Regards Paladino- Debbie says that he is "helping" welfare recipients- didnt he say that he wants to create "work camps" for welfare recipients out of old prisons? Is that really the kind of help that poor people need in our country today. Is that really a message of good government? Carls record of using public money as the source of his wealth does tip of some of us to his hypocritical dissemblings.
Al 28 Aug 2010, 22:52
"Debbie" you seemed to have missed the point of this column. Did you ever leave your small-town and pick up different perspectives? If you live in a glass house, don't be throwing rocks at me. NY State is not some building that can purchased and left to rot. The people of NY deserve a progressive leader without baggage full of bigotry.
gian 30 Aug 2010, 21:20
I read this column, and think left-wing moonbat, throw paper in garbage. next time I see stack of a/v, pick up stack of papers throw in dumpter, repeat every week.
Michael S. 31 Aug 2010, 10:07
Gian, If you feel the need to destory copies of a publication in order validate your own self worth and agenda, please do so in an environmentally friendly way. Find a recycling bin. By the way... Mike's columns aren't published every week... So maybe you just have a bone to pick with Artvoice? Considering Artvoice also acts as a healthy cross-section and listing for local events, eateries, shops, and arts, your actions will be to the detriment of Buffalo as a whole. A more constructive action would be to display his article, construct an argument against it, and submit it to the editor. These retorts ARE published in copy. Maybe that way you'll utilize formerly dormant areas of your frontal lobe rather than calling someone a 'moonbat' (whatever the hell that is) and dismissing their rhetoric with even less brainpower. Peace, homes.
Jeff Zettl 31 Aug 2010, 17:37
This guy Neiman is all upset over the emails and his favorite one (because he is able to describe it so well), concerning the woman and horse. Why does he not take a stand over Artvoice taking porn advertising which appears every week. Does anybody but me see some kind of double standard here?
ElissaF 09 Jun 2011, 10:51
Jeff - I'm not certain that Mike is upset over Paladino's emails as much as wanting to expose what a slimebucket he is, especially as he's posing now as a good guy! one of the people! The people include those of us who don't like our politicians to be racist sexist scumbags. |
|
Issue Navigation> Issue Index > v9n34 (week of Thursday, August 26) > Our Zany March Toward Intolerance This Week's Issue • Artvoice Daily • Artvoice TV • Events Calendar • Classifieds |







