Comments (0)
Leave a comment
More From Artvoice

OneTaste Forced Labor Case Shows How 'Cult' Label Framed Prosecution
The article examines how years of media coverage labeling OneTaste an “orgasm cult” shaped the context around the forced labor conspiracy case against Nicole Daedone and Rachel Cherwitz.

SOMOZA OUTSMARTED TRANSAMERICA. THE DOJ MADE HIM PAY FOR IT.
Rev. J. Benjamin Hardwick and Curtis Somoza created a life insurance program for poor South Los Angeles congregants, funded by investors and insured by Transamerica. Early deaths, delayed payouts and federal intervention turned the plan into a fraud case.

Ben Simmons Is Back In The NBA After A Year Off Signing A $3.5 Million Deal With The Sacramento Kings
Ben Simmons is back in the NBA. The 30-year-old three-time All-Star agreed Friday to a one-year, $3.5 million contract with the Sacramento Kings, the only team to offer him a deal after what has been…

Alcohol Cancer Deaths Have Doubled In 33 Years, Study Finds
A study published September 2 in The Lancet Regional Health, Americas by researchers at the University of Miami's Sylvester Comprehensive Cancer Center found that alcohol-attributable cancer deaths…

NXIVM insiders, deep within Raniere’s inner circle, used the training as a way to gather information on those they could extort what Raniere wanted from them:
The list goes on.
People want to make those who received benefits from the training as a powerful defense for Raniere.
This is not about who benefits from a training program, this is about Raniere and his partners’ illegal actions.
***
The prosecution might wish to show that, despite grandiose claims of NXIVM being an organization developed for the benefit of its students, it had really no other objective than to serve its founder, Keith Raniere’s selfish ends.
In this Raniere had some co conspirators and enablers. Among the chief ones were Nancy Salzman, Karen Unterreiner, Lauren Salzman, Clare Bronfman, Sara Bronfman, Emiliano Salinas, Alejandro Betancourt, Allison Mack and others – some of whom defected. The ones who defected prior to the fall of Raniere deserve, in my mind and in most case, absolution for their misdeeds and to not be listed as co conspirators – even though they may have done as much or more to build up Raniere’s dark and bifurcated world of deceit [while pretending to be a noble Vanguard] than some of those listed above.
In some cases, the defectors contributed to the fall of Raniere. In varying degrees, I think all the co conspirators were both victims and victimizers. In my next post, I will try to illustrate this with a rumination on Clare Bronfman – one of the least sympathetic and vicious of the co conspirators.
***
As for the eight things Raniere’s NXIVM was really all about – to him –
— I am pretty sure we can think of a few others – perks the Vanguard received, or attempted to receive, [none of which he seems to be enjoying now]. I think they all boils down to one primary thing, however: NXIVM was run for the benefit of Keith Raniere – and he alone- although he did let co conspirators enjoy to some degree.
I suspect Raniere derived a sadistic pleasure in watching “fools” worship him [he who had the worst intentions towards them] and see them operate a community, and a mission in his name, where the “fools” [in his eyes, they are ‘fools’] thought they were really trying to do good – who actually really tried to do good – while he manipulated them to serve his selfish ends alone.
And, yes, sure, there were good things in the NXIVM courses. There had to be. Otherwise, the ‘fools’ would not pay tens of thousands for courses – and go into to debt to take more – while trying to recruit others, and serving the mission for free.
But the courses were intended to keep people hooked – that is why the curriculum was endless – no one ever graduates – no one ever achieves the final result — ‘unification’ – he called it.
He would – in the guise of mentor or leader – – worshipful Vanguard – who was thanked in every class for his munificence and brilliance – thwart all their efforts – with many efforts of his own to trip them up along the way — as one judge rightly called his intentions toward Toni Natalie – for their own individual -not Vanguard created – success.
Raniere was constantly creating unnecessary chaos – to prevent success and keep people enslaved. For success for his ‘fools’ was antithetical to Raniere’s goals for Executive Success Programs. Success for them might have meant freedom for his fools/slaves/devotees/students. It was adversarial – but his students did not know it.
He – the man who defines winning as crucial – even in things that should be shared and not measured in comparatives – such as joy – won by enslaving his followers. Keeping them abject – never seeking their success through equality.
This, I believe, is where the secret of drawing the line between victimizer and victim lies. Many of his most ardent followers were a mix of both.
I think, for instance, that Allison Mack – in her heart and brain – actually, honestly thought [or was trained to think] his was a mission of goodness – even DOS. I doubt she was ‘out there’ hating the people she recruited. Somewhere she got caught up in his web of lies, and entered a dim world balanced between wanting to keep her fine [and selfish] role with Raniere [procuring him, for example, fuck toys and etc.] and a world – in her head – where a more deeply embedded hypnotic suggestion lay- where she must serve Raniere for his noble mission – which is for the welfare of a troubled and needlessly suffering world. There were times when his mere voice, a look or a suggestion would reduce her to tears – so eager was she programmed to believe he was sheer goodness.