Artvoice: Buffalo's #1 Newsweekly
Home Blogs Web Features Calendar Listings Artvoice TV Real Estate Classifieds Contact
Previous story: Letters to Artvoice
Next story: Free Will Astrology

International Security: Bush Wants the Best of Both Worlds

The Buffalo Niagara region is taking another big hit from the Bush administration, a 50 percent cut in federal homeland security funding, amounting to about $3.6 million. The funding typically goes to training programs for first responders (e.g. fire, police and EMTs), border security and other preparedness programs. On top of that, there has been serious talk in Washington about requiring those crossing the US-Canada border to present a passport or special ID card. The change, scheduled to take place in January 2008, could make it costly and downright inconvenient to visit our friends, families, and everything we love about our sister community across the river, Ontario. To the binational tourism industry, the change in policy could mean the loss of millions of dollars in revenue. We went to the streets to find out what Western New Yorkers think.

Name: Jean Murphy

Occupation: Executive assistant

Residence: North Tonawanda

With the proposed cut in funding, will Buffalo’s first responder units be well prepared in the event of an emergency? Absolutely not, I think we need all the funding we need in this area especially with the close proximity to an international border such as Canada.

How do you feel the proposed changes would affect you as a member of the community living along the international border? It would affect me adversely; as a matter of fact I have trouble getting over the border with the strictness of some of the toll takers now. They’ve threatened to turn me back because I didn’t have a passport. I understand they need to protect the border but not to the determent of US citizens crossing.

If a passport or a border ID becomes mandatory, will it deter you and your family from traveling across the river? It most certainly will. I was ready to turn around and go home when I was being given such grief by the inspector that particular day.

Name: Tim Martin

Occupation: Retired/music teacher

Residence: Buffalo

With the proposed cut in funding, will Buffalo’s first responder units be well prepared in the event of an emergency? I don’t think so.

How do you feel the proposed changes would affect you as a member of the community living along the international border? Well, we won’t feel as secure as we’d like to feel.

If a passport or a border ID becomes mandatory, will it deter you and your family from traveling across the river? Yeah, I like to go across the border just to take a walk on the other side. You know, little situations like that. There would be more impact on our budgets; it should be rejected.

Name: Tim Sweeney

Occupation: Social worker

Residence: Glenwood

With the proposed cut in funding, will Buffalo’s first responder units be well prepared in the event of an emergency? Absolutely not, we are on an international border and if you are going to use all that money—as opposed to things like education, which they’ve cut—it should be on the border not in the heartland. Although I suppose they could attack anyplace. But it’s certainly going to hurt this area.

How do you feel the proposed changes would affect you as a member of the community living along the international border? Well, I think that the things with the ID cards or whatever, that’s ridiculous. We are kind of a community with Canada.

If a passport or a border ID becomes mandatory, will it deter you and your family from traveling across the river? Yes.